Born in Riverhead, New York
Sergio's Pizza opened in Riverhead on Long Island in 1975. Nearly fifty years in, the same honest New York pie, nothing changed.
Sergio's Pizza | Our Story
A Corner Shop in Riverhead
In 1975, Sergio opened his doors in Riverhead — a no-frills slice shop that set out to make classic New York pizza and nothing else. That original location is still there, still doing exactly that.
The Pizza Hasn't Changed
Same sturdy crust, bright tomato sauce, real mozzarella — the same dough and sauce recipe at every location. No shortcuts, no reinvention.
A Name That Means Something
Regulars have come back for decades. Which is why we started opening up new locations all over the map!
From Brooklyn to South Jordan
Four locations now — Brooklyn, Riverhead, Malta, and South Jordan. East Coasters say it tastes exactly like home, no matter how far from the island.
